Letter to the Editor: There are too many unknowns, vague talking points and lack of information in city’s plan to change government structure
May 9 Special Election
 By  John Few Published 
8:26 am Wednesday, April 12, 2023

Letter to the Editor: There are too many unknowns, vague talking points and lack of information in city’s plan to change government structure

Dear Editor,
In Madison’s special election on May 9th, I will be voting no. I will be voting no because I care about Madison’s future and the voting rights of its citizens.
The proposed Council-Manager form of government takes away the voters’ right to directly choose the person who runs the city. A city manager is selected by the council and by the mayor. It disrupts the separation and balance of power by making the mayor a legislator and placing a selected individual into an executive position of power. The executive branch is completely controlled by the legislators. The appointed executive would have no veto power to check the consolidated power of the council.

Finally, there are simply too many unknowns about how the council-manager form of government would function, and more notably, a significant lack of information regarding financial cost, despite inquiries. Madison’s website even has a question about salaries of the mayor and city manager as a FAQ and the answer is “For both forms of government, salaries have not yet been defined”. Voters would be able to make an informed decision if there was a comprehensive cost and benefit analysis. In the absence of such an analysis, voters should vote “no” simply because they do not have all of the information needed to make an informed decision.

The biggest question that resounds among citizens is simply, why? Why does Madison need a fundamental change in the government’s structure? I have yet to hear a satisfactory answer to this question other than shallow talking points. “For Madison’s future!” “Continuity!” “Best to fix it before anything is broken!”
I see two possible scenarios. Scenario 1: Our current mayor and council are incompetent, so we need a change. (Why not just vote them out in the next election if they’re so horrible?) Scenario 2: Our current mayor and council are competent. (So why do we need a change? Just elect them again if you want “continuity” of their efforts).

Except those in favor of the proposition repeatedly cite one of their reasons for wanting the change is that it would help Madison to run more like a business– it would take the politics out of it. What they really mean is that a fundamental change in our government’s structure would take the VOTER out of it. In both aforementioned scenarios, the fate of those sitting in positions of power are directly determined by the voice of the voter. It doesn’t seem like they like the idea of Madison’s future actually being in the hands of the voter. They want to take the voter out of the equation so their goals for the city can be achieved without interruption by the everyday citizens electing officials that do not support what they envision for Madison.

In conclusion, vote NO to preserve Madison’s voter rights, and especially vote NO because citizens have not been provided with sufficient information in order to make an informed decision.

Sincerely,

Tiffany Knox

Also on The Madison Record
A: Main, Madison County Record, News, ...
Staff Reports 
November 18, 2026
MADISON - Madison has been named the second best small city in America by Livability. com. In its inaugural list of the 50 Best Small Cities, the data...
A brother’s legacy builds joy for children battling cancer
A: Main, Lifestyles, Madison County Record, ...
Ten years after Josh Quist’s passing, his sister revives a LEGO toy drive to bring comfort and creativity to local children fighting cancer
Staff Reports 
November 18, 2026
HUNTSVILLE — For Josh Quist, a LEGO set offered something childhood cancer couldn’t take away: the freedom to imagine, create and simply be a kid. Ten...
Bartlett salutes Armed Forces whose service ‘spans decades and continents’
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
MADISON WEEKLY
Gregg Parker 
November 18, 2026
MADISON – In appreciation for all military personnel, Mayor Ranae Bartlett and Councilmembers Billie Goodson, Alice Lessmann and Erica White represent...
14 arrested in Limestone County sting targeting online child exploitation
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
WES TOMLINSON The Decatur Daily 
November 18, 2026
LIMESTONE COUNTY - Fourteen men were arrested recently in an undercover operation targeting online child exploitation, the Limestone County Sheriff’s ...
TARCOG assists Town of Triana in developing up-todate comprehensive plan
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
Gregg Parker 
November 18, 2026
TRIANA – With growth comes change, and leaders in the Town of Triana are working to keep the town’s priorities on track by updating its Comprehensive ...
Forget-Me-Not seminar to train caregivers for dementia, Alzheimer’s disease patients
Events, Lifestyles, News, ...
Gregg Parker 
November 18, 2026
MADISON – Unfortunately, a diagnosis of dementia will affect practically everyone at some point – either in a personal evaluation or in the diagnosis ...
Movement Church to give food to cook Thanksgiving meal
Events, Lifestyles, Madison County Record, ...
Gregg Parker 
November 18, 2026
MADISON – With Thanksgiving Day approaching quickly, one Madison church is doing its part for residents to enjoy a tasty holiday meal. Movement Church...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *