• 48°
The Madison Record

Editorial: Space Command decision again under shadow

From The Decatur Daily

The U.S. General Accounting Office has released its report on the decision to move the U.S. Space Command from its provisional home in Colorado to Redstone Arsenal in Huntsville.

Despite what some state and local officials would have you believe, the report is not a vindication of the decision, made under the administration of President Donald Trump, to place Space Command’s permanent headquarters in Alabama. Far from it. It opens the door for President Joe Biden’s administration to revisit the issue. Huntsville is not out of the woods yet.

Space Command is the Air Force division that oversees satellite-based navigation and troop communication and provides warning of missile launches. It’s not to be confused with the U.S. Space Force, which President Donald Trump spun out of the Air Force into its own service branch.

Meeting participants “had conflicting recollections of who picked Alabama over Colorado,” AP reported. “But in selecting the base’s move to Alabama, the decision went against the recommendations of the U.S. Space Command combatant commander, the U.S. Space Force chief of Space Operations and the former vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. They had recommended that the operation remain in Colorado.”

Alabama Sen. Richard Shelby acted as if the GAO report didn’t say what any neutral observer could read for himself, tweeting: “Pleased that the @USGAO Space Command report reiterates what the IG report said last month. The @USAirForce followed strict criteria when they evaluated and selected Huntsville. I agree that Huntsville was the right pick for the job.”

“Strict criteria” is doing a lot of heavy lifting here. The criteria may have been strict, but they were also suspect.

“GAO found that while the Air Force’s revised basing process was comprehensive, it was also biased, not credible and not sufficiently documented,” reported Defense News. “The agency took issue with the service’s lack of documented ground rules, assumptions and constraints and found it failed to conduct key sensitive analysis and independent reviews.

“For example, the report notes the service didn’t apply consistent weighting criteria when it chose between the six finalists.”

Alabama lawmakers and Huntsville officials glossed over all of this, claiming the report ruled out political interference (it didn’t) and reaffirmed that Redstone led in all the site criteria (the criteria the report found inconsistent).

The GAO report couldn’t rule out political interference because the report couldn’t even determine who made the final decision.

“Although the Air Force documented the general rationale for selecting Redstone Arsenal in an action memorandum and accompanying documents, there was not consensus among the officials we interviewed regarding who ultimately made the decision to name Redstone Arsenal as the preferred location for U.S. Space Command headquarters, including the role of the then-president in making the decision,” the report says.

But it just so happens the headquarters went from a state that had just voted overwhelmingly for Biden to one that voted overwhelmingly for Trump.

Colorado lawmakers have requested that the Biden administration reconsider the Space Command move. We’re not sure what Biden will do, but Huntsville had better hope the current president isn’t as interested in settling scores as the last was.

 

Harvest

World War II veteran Major Wooten, 105, loved country and his family

Madison

Madison Street Festival celebrates 40th anniversary in big way

Madison

Have a fun scare at library’s Mad Movie-A-Thon-O-Rama!

Madison

Space Week takes Horizon students on aerospace, tech discoveries

Madison

City urges caution as paving progresses on Hughes Road

Bob Jones High School

Madison City Chess League forms new group for adults

Madison

Madison City Schools named best Alabama school district

Madison

Mercy Wolverton impressively masters hi-tech study, business

Madison

At Madison Street Festival, veterans to show fighter helicopter from Vietnam War

Madison

Local marching bands to be featured at “March on Madison” tonight

Madison

MSF’s Community Showcase promises array of talent

Madison

Brooms, mops in Lions Club sale to raise funds for vision projects

Harvest

Local musicians to jam at Madison Street Festival

Madison

Trash Pandas fall 4-2, Tennessee evens series

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

Athletic Hall Of Fame Accepting Nominations

Harvest

Railyard BBQ Brawl and Music Festival returns Oct. 29

Bob Jones High School

Tommy Overcash appointed to Madison Board of Education

Madison

Children vulnerable for troubled mental health, Cook says

Madison

Fast start leads Trash Pandas to 9-5 in playoff game 1 win

Harvest

Updating state’s 1901 Constitution on November ballot

James Clemens High School

Boynton champions languages with ‘A Seal of Biliteracy’

Madison

Jessica Penot to discuss ‘Haunted North Alabama’

Madison

MSF shows artistic influences at Artist Alley, Crafters Cove and Student Art Tent

Bob Jones High School

Bob Jones, James Clemens command National Merit totals for Alabama

x